Where to Get the Best Dessert in Pigeon Forge

Updated 4/2/25

Pigeon Forge may be best known for its family-friendly attractions, stunning mountain scenery, and Southern charm—but don’t overlook its dessert scene. This Smoky Mountain town is a hidden gem for anyone with a sweet tooth, offering everything from sky-high milkshakes and handcrafted fudge to artisan cupcakes and nostalgic candies.

Whether you’re winding down after a day of sightseeing or craving a sweet treat between attractions, these dessert spots are among the best in town. Here’s where to find the best dessert in Pigeon Forge—each one worth saving room for.

---

Best Chocolate Desserts in Pigeon Forge

Big Rock Candy Kitchen

Big Rock Candy Kitchen, nestled in the heart of The Island in Pigeon Forge, combines the charm of a vintage candy shop with a modern twist. The smell of freshly made fudge hits you as soon as you walk through the door. They offer a huge variety of handcrafted chocolates, caramel-dipped apples, chocolate-drenched pretzels, and other small-batch goodies. But it’s not all about tradition—they’ve got quirky novelty candies too, like massive gummy creatures and sour-packed treats your kids (and inner child) will love.

Try This: Their classic chocolate walnut fudge is creamy, rich, and made fresh daily.

Location: The Island in Pigeon Forge

---

Old Mill Candy Kitchen

Tucked into the Old Mill Historic District, this beloved shop crafts its sweets right in front of you. Watch through glass windows as candy-makers spin taffy, dip apples, and pour molten fudge onto marble slabs. The Old Mill Candy Kitchen leans into classic Southern-style sweets like peanut brittle, divinity, and hand-pulled taffy. It’s a nostalgic experience that blends history and indulgence in one stop.

Don’t Miss: Their chocolate-dipped pecan clusters and traditional Smoky Mountain taffy.

Location: Next to The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge

---

Top Ice Cream Spots in Pigeon Forge

Titanic Ice Cream

Right next to the iconic Titanic Museum Attraction, this ice cream shop is a lesser-known gem that deserves more attention. Titanic Ice Cream offers frozen custards and unique sundaes, including the standout “Heart of the Ocean Blend”—a creamy creation topped with butterscotch, cinnamon toast crunch, and blue heart sprinkles. It’s a whimsical, Titanic-themed treat that’s just as photo-worthy as it is tasty. Beyond ice cream, you’ll also find muffins, cake pops, and other sweet and savory snacks on the menu.

Sweet Surprise: The Heart of the Ocean sundae, perfect for fans of dessert and drama.

Location: 2132 Parkway, right beside the Titanic Museum

---

Mad Dog’s Creamery

Mad Dog’s Creamery is bright, colorful, and laid-back—just the way a good ice cream spot should be. Their Pigeon Forge location features a wide variety of hand-dipped and soft-serve flavors, plus fresh donuts, funnel cakes, and milkshakes made to order. What really makes this spot stand out is its dog-friendly atmosphere—complete with pup treats and outdoor seating for you and your four-legged travel buddy.

Top Pick: Strawberry shortcake sundae with a side of warm funnel cake for dipping.

Location: 3048 Parkway

---

Old Mill Creamery

The Old Mill Creamery takes a homespun approach to ice cream, churning each batch in-house using fresh, local ingredients. Many of their flavors are inspired by the bakery and distillery next door—think Oatmeal Cream Pie or Whiskey Ribbon, a decadent blend infused with local moonshine and swirled with fudge. You’ll also find traditional favorites like Cookies & Cream and Butter Pecan, all served with that unmistakable Southern hospitality.

Planning a picnic or family gathering? Grab their Family Quart Pack, which includes two quarts of your favorite flavors, toppings, and serving gear—all in a handy Old Mill tote. Hosting a larger group? Go big with the Party Gallon, a 2.5-gallon tub of ice cream ready to feed a crowd (preorders recommended!).

Local Favorite: Whiskey Ribbon—rich, velvety, and just a little rebellious.

Location: Old Mill Square

---

Bakeries You Can’t Miss in Pigeon Forge

Gigi’s Cupcakes

If you’re a frosting person, welcome to your happy place. Gigi’s Cupcakes is known for its generous swirls of frosting and rotating lineup of cupcake flavors that range from classic to wildly creative. Expect everything from Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and Salted Caramel to seasonal specials like Peppermint Hot Chocolate. They also offer indulgent gluten-free options, rich mini cheesecakes, and decadent mini cakes that can be ordered ahead for your next celebration.

Insider Tip: Get a 4-pack sampler to try more than one flavor—trust us, choosing just one is impossible.

Location: Teaster Lane

---

Cinnaholic

Nestled in the Mountain Mile Shopping Center, Cinnaholic is a build-your-own cinnamon roll shop that’s completely vegan yet packed with rich flavor. Start with a warm cinnamon roll base, then go wild with frostings, toppings, and drizzles. Whether you’re into peanut butter, cookie dough, or fresh fruit, the combinations are endless. Despite being plant-based, the rolls are sweet, sticky, and absolutely indulgent.

Fan Favorite: A roll loaded with strawberries, cookie dough, and cream cheese frosting.

Location: Mountain Mile

---

Sweet Treats for the Whole Family in Pigeon Forge

TopJump Trampoline & Extreme Arena

After bouncing around this action-packed attraction, refuel at the massive candy wall inside the main lobby. With rows of bulk candy bins and retro favorites, it’s an ideal stop for kids and kids-at-heart who want to mix up their own custom stash of sweets.

Best For Kids: Let them fill a bag with whatever catches their eye—there’s no wrong combo.

Location: 3735 Parkway

---

Crave Golf Club

Crave Golf Club is part mini-golf course, part dessert dreamland. The candy-themed décor sets the scene with oversized sweets, vibrant colors, and plenty of photo-worthy spots. Inside, you’ll find a bulk candy shop packed with gummies, chocolates, and nostalgic treats—as well as soft serve ice cream you can enjoy in a cup or cone. Whether you’re wrapping up a round of mini golf or just swinging by for a sugar rush, it’s a sweet stop for all ages.

Family Favorite: Mix and match your favorite treats from the candy wall, then cool off with a swirl of soft serve on the side.

Location: 2925 Parkway

---

Apple Valley Creamery

Just a short drive from Pigeon Forge in nearby Sevierville, a stop at Apple Valley Creamery feels like a step into simpler times. Their ice cream is made on-site with high-quality ingredients and served in generous scoops. You’ll find both classic flavors and seasonal specials, often tied to what’s fresh in the Smoky Mountains. Right next door, you can pick up apple cobbler, pies, and other Southern baked goods at the Apple Barn’s bakery.

Southern Classic: Apple cobbler topped with a big scoop of vanilla bean ice cream.

Location: Apple Barn Village

---

Want More Sweets?

Looking for more local dessert spots, fudge shops, or candy stores? Check out our Desserts & Candy section under “Things to Do” for even more sweet adventures and brochures from around town.

---

Final Bite

From chocolate-dipped treats to photo-worthy milkshakes, the dessert scene in Pigeon Forge is brimming with both unexpected gems and beloved family favorites. Whatever sweets you’re craving, there’s a spot in town to satisfy your taste—just bring your appetite (and maybe a to-go box).

Content on this page is subject to change. Please contact the locations mentioned to see if promotions, hours, pricing, etc. are still valid.